Fashion Girls

Ball and Chain

Last night, I attended my law firm's holiday part - a grand fete at the Ritz Carlton. (Yep, that was me, in the beaded palazzo pants, with the beaded cami, and the gauzy overblouse, all in black.) Most of the evening was spent gossiping with coworkers - I won't bore you with the details. The one thing I will share is this lesson, sadly learned by the date of one of my co-workers: Don't attend your significant other's company holiday party, get drunk, pretend to be a partner at a major law firm in town, and then fondle the behind of another party guest. Especially when that guest is the wife of a former Olympic-contender wrestler. Really.

Elsewhere in my little world, I've been reading a number of the comments and debate brought about by Holly Lisle's comments about how chain bookstores are horrific for writers and should be avoided, boycotted, and destroyed at all costs. (Here are Holly's comments: http://hollylisle.com/writingdiary2/index.php/2006/12/01/selling-to-the-net-or

Other people have commented here:  http://difrancis.livejournal.com/51301.html and here:  http://sgreer.livejournal.com/350353.html and likely in many, many places I haven't browsed through this afternoon.

And here are my comments in reply, which I originally posted over on Bookseller Chick's blog ( http://booksellerchick.blogspot.com/ ):

Alas, all indies are not alike, and any analysis of the industry that assumes all indies are the same isn't a complete analysis.

The indies I know best (the Olssons chain in Washington DC) are not supportive of speculative fiction, particularly the paranormals I'm currently writing. Most indies I've patronized skew very, very heavily toward "literature", with a handful dedicated to specific genres (e.g. mystery or SF.)

I am hundreds of times more likely to find my books in chain stores than in indies. I'd be biting the hands that feed me if I spoke out against all chains in favor of all indies. At the same time, I support any indy that supports genre (especially my genres) - I'll try to arrange readings/signings at them, I'll send them promotional materials (if they can use them), I'll include them on my chocolate gift list for book launches, I'll mention them and their staff on my blog....

I'd love to live in a book world where there were omnipresent genre-friendly indies. I'd love to live in a world where there were omniscient chain store employees. Living in *this* world, though, I balance the best I can - support the stores that support me, and educate, educate, educate...

So.  What do you folks think? 

Mindy, who is sparing you the mundaniana of a Sunday spent catching up on laundry, closet-cleaning, cooking, bringing books to the Library booksale, etc.

Comments

I think that I've already accepted that fact that I'll never support myself by writing, so anyone who is willing to sell any book I (finally!) get published is fine with me, be it via the net or the store.

Course, right now I just need a finished novel to pitch to an agent, so my opinion doesn't mean much. :P
Hey - your opinion means a lot! As a book buyer, a book reader, *and* as a book writer. And recognizing that your not likely to be able to quit the proverbial day-job.... Well, that means a lot too. Realism. We writers need to specialize in it.
DH and I were discussing this very issue a few weeks ago for some reason. I think it was because I hadn't found a book I wanted buy at the local BN.

To be honest, I'm of two minds on this. I've discovered a lot more 'new' authors by browsing the shelves at chain bookstores. My only real beef with them is for not stocking the first book in a series.

Since I buy books both on the internet and in the chains [and at used bookstores, etc] I'm not going to get into the arguement that one is better than the other, etc. Each has their strong points, and each has the opportunity to give me what I want; a good book to read.
That first book thing is a biggie - it's really frustrating to have a series out there, but have no one buy later volumes because they can't find earlier ones. Some publishers are better than others at pushing stores to buy earlier volumes. I've been pleased that Roc tended to promote APPRENTICE as future volumes come out.

Somewhat oddly - I usually find books 1, 3, and 5 in my series; 2 and 4 appear with less frequency. ::shrugs::
You should be pleased to know that the BN by us has the all five books in the Glasswright series. At least, they did when I last checked.

My views are pretty much the same. In Davis, where I used to live, they had 2 indies that were genre friendly, but they didn't stock the obscure stuff. At the same time though, they did recommend books from the other genres if you were looking for something to read.

The indies in Orlando weren't very friendly at all. I went to a signing for a mystery writer and they weren't friendly to him at all nor were they really all that interested that nobody was coming to the signing. And a browse through their bookstore showed that there were no good books anywhere. I swear they had a total of 20 books in the store.

So even though chain stores may be the Big Bad, indies really aren't that helpful either.
Of course, there are *great* indies out there. One of the best book events I've ever attended was at Bakka, in Toronto (an SF indy.) Of course, if I had to travel to Toronto every time I wanted to buy a genre book, I'd be making far fewer book purchases :-)

My college roommate went to vet school at Davis. I was only up there once, and it was hot, hot, hot - and tomato harvest season, which made it fun to watch those giant open trucks on the clover leafs...
There are some great indy bookstores in the San Francisco Bay area as well. I meant that not all indies are built the same. It's not a catch-all that indies are always better than chain stores.

Yeah, Davis is hot during the summer. But at least it's a dry heat. The heat in Florida is wet and I just want to die!

There are tomatoes everywhere on the corners of curbs during tomato season. If you're up there again, give them a WIDE birth, and I mean WIDE. Them suckers tip easy and have a hard time slowing down.
I love all bookstores. I may not shop in all of them, but I love them anyway. :)
You know, I really *do* get a little rush every time I step into one. Sick me. Poor, sick me. Poor, broke me. :-)
I know the feeling. Working at a bookstore doesn't help the situation, lol. That employee discount is too tempting... :)
I'll get books anywhere I can find them. Antiquarian booksellers if I can afford them, Bakka, dealers at cons, chainstores ... heck, the first SF I bought was off the magazine rack in a drugstore in Palatka, Florida. It's all good.
When I was a kid, growing up in Dallas, my best friend and I used to walk to a comic book store (which also had a bunch of SF fan stuff) and spend *hours* browsing, to spend our measly 2 or 3 dollars. We'd finish the trip by walking to a Woolworth's, getting French Fries and Cokes at the food counter, and browsing the paperback racks.

I assume that both stores have been gone for 25 years...