Fashion Girls

Old Home Week - Katherine Kurtz Edition

When I was in seventh grade, I discovered Katherine Kurtz.  I inhaled her first Deryni series (at the time, her *only* Deryni series), and Alaric Anthony Morgan became my dream man.  I read the books so many times that I had large portions of them memorized, and I spent long evenings on the phone with my then-best-friend debating minor points about Catholicism and magic.

When I finished writing the Trunked Novel (the one that first got me an agent, but which never sold, and boy aren't all of you grateful for that!), I rented a motel room on the Outer Banks, drove down with the manuscript pages, my coffee maker (for making pots of tea - I never made coffee with the thing), and that same trilogy.  I alternated editing, walks on the beach, and more Morgan/Kelson/Duncan adventures, and I hated my manuscript because I knew that it would never work as well as Kurtz's series.

I read the Camber of Culdi series, and then the new Kelson series, and then the new Camber series, and I became depressed and despairing, as it became clear - in KING JAVAN'S YEAR - that every single person in the Kurtz-world was destined for unbearable heartache and loss.  I read the Adam Sinclair non-Deryni series, and I loved the notion of a fantasy series working like a mystery series - open-ended adventures, without a concrete "trilogy" plot - even though Sinclair himself didn't completely grip me.  I read LAMMAS NIGHT and was intrigued by the Nazi/magic intersection, but I loaned my copy to the then-best-friend, who I have now not seen in more than 15 years, alas.

And then I read ST PATRICK'S GARGOYLE - a slight novel.  A disappointing novel.  A novel without the character depth and setting detail and plot construction that I had loved in so many others.  I decided that I had outgrown Katherine Kurtz.

Several months ago, I was working in San Francisco, and I visited with my now-best-friend, another Kurtz reader.  She had IN THE KING'S SERVICE and CHILDE MORGAN, which I borrowed from her.  I picked up KING'S SERVICE earlier this week, and I'm having a wonderful time.

I love meeting characters who are ancient in the Kelson books.  I love meeting characters who I can tell are parents or grandparents of characters in the Kelson books.  I love being reminded of the simple stolidity of Deryni powers, the confidence with which Kurtz defines who can do what.  I love the jolting familiarity of setting - of *course* there's a Transfer Portal in Rhemuth Cathedral; I know it well.

Yeah, there's a little too much focus on dynasties and succession law.  Yeah, the plot skips huge chunks of time.  Yeah, there isn't a "through-line" with a single character (or even multiple POV characters) building the plot.

But I am truly enjoying this return to my youth, to my writing roots, to my first total-escape fantasy world.

What about you?  What are your guilty return reads?

Mindy, dashing off to read a few more pages before work
Tags:

Comments

I still am adding to my list of guilty return reads, but I'd say mainly Christopher Pike. The man is pretty hit and miss. I've re-read stuff of his that I've absolutely hated, and rediscovered stuff that I still love with him.

That, and any Jane Yolen, K.A. Applegate, and Bruce Coville, among others.
What a perfect icon for your answering my question! :-)
Thanks! It's my reading icon. Yomiko Readman from Read or Die. She's a superhero with magical powers that allow her to manipulate paper.
Tamora Pierce's Song of the Lioness series, even though I've read her to the point of being sick of her. One (mostly) stand-alone I've never grown tired of, though, is Robin McKinley's The Blue Sword.
I came to Tamora Pierce late, but I can readily see how she would hold that position on many folks' reading lists!
My very first fantasy/sci-fi type book that I ever read was a children series by Lloyd Alexander who wrote "The Chronicles of Prydain". My mother was a music teacher and because she wanted us to read over the summer, she'd bring home books from the school library (the librarian was her friend) and we'd read over the summer. Made my dad mad because my nose was stuck in a book instead of looking at the rolling praries of Idaho or Montana (forget which) while on vacation. I read that one at least five times growing up. I've not revisited it in a long time but for the longest time, that was the type of fantasy I read, the quest. At the moment, I'm on a murder/mystery kick. I've also reread some of Mercedes Lackey books especially the first ones.

And on that note, I wanted to ask. Are you planning on Worldcon this year in Denver? If so, maybe we'll be able to meet. I'm working on the "staff lounge" staff...:)
Ah, Prydain... I've been meaning to re-read those...

Alas, Worldcon isn't likely to be in my future. I'm doing a *ton* of travel for work, and it's really hard for me to fold in additional trips right now. If, though, things change, you *know* I'll hang out at the staff lounge, just to meet you in person!
I actually discovered the Deryni books a few weeks ago, and I should be too old to develop crushes on fictive characters, but Alaric .... *drools*

Guilty return reads - and my first character crushes - the Hornblower series and The Three Musketeers plus sequel (it was Athos, in case you wonder).

When I feel like reading pure, unadultered D&D style Fantasy, I still like to go back to Feist's first Riftwar books and Edding's Elenium. After all the grey characters you'll find in Fantasy these days, it's actually nice to have good and bad ones for a change. Not that I don't appreciate the grey characters, of course, I like A Song of Ice and Fire.

Non guilty rereads would be Rosemary Sutcliff and German hist fic YA writer Barbara Bartos-Höppner.



I think it was your comment that pushed my husband over the edge. He said, "What is it with this Alaric Anthony Morgan guy?" I just shrugged and tried to explain - not very effectively. What, am I back in middle school? :-)
We're fangrlz and there's no way out. :)

But men have their own guilty pleasures. In case of my brother it's an electric model helicopter he's flying around whenever time and wind permit. There's a little boy still hiding somewhere. ;)
It's obscure, and I can't even tell you for certain that this is the title, but there was a children's novel called War Between the Pitiful Teachers and the Splendid Kids, by Stanley Kiesel, I believe. It's a strange blend of comedy, surrealism, tragedy, and at its end, apocalpytica. It still stands out in my mind today, and I try to revisit it every couple of years. The book is still amazing, even as an adult. I only wish I could find a new copy, as mine is in tatters from countless rereads.

It's essentially the tale of a light-hearted miscreant named Skinny, who goes to war with his friends against all the injustices thrust upon them in school. It would never be published today, I think, as it has some surprisingly nasty elements to it. But with such oddities as shark-infested pudding, golf cart wars, and one of the most achingly sad endings in any novel I've read, it's a definite must find.
Sounds fascinating - I'll have to see if I can dig it up! YA is publishing some surprising things today - some *truly* nasty - but not necessarily wildly creative...
My first spec fic reads were all Andre Norton YAs. When I read them now, I think they mostly hold up pretty well as YAs, but they're not what I like to read now.

The one book I still love as much as the first time I read it is THE SECRET GARDEN by Frances Hodgson Burnett. Still a wonderful story!
I as given a copy of THE SECRET GARDEN when I was a young girl, and I couldn't get into it at all. I finally read it while I was in law school - after seeing the musical, of all things - and I enjoyed it then!
I love to go back and reread books that are special to me in some way.

The books I reread most often would be the Jane Austen oeuvre and The Lord of the Rings

Last year I went on a rereading tour through the works of Joanna Russ, James Tiptree/Alice Sheldon, and Charles R. Saunders.

Sometimes I get into a mood to reread some of the early masters, like Heinlein, Brackett, C.L.Moore, Asimov, Clarke, Van Vogt, Kuttner, Norton, Sturgeon, and su on.

Series that I go back to again and again include:
Katherine Kurtz' Deryni books
Anne McCaffrey's Dragon books
Marion Zimmer Bradley's Darkover books
Mercedes Lackey's Heralds of Valdemar books
Mercedes Lackey's Diana Tregarde books
Elizabeth Moon's Paksenarrion books
Douglas Adams' Hitchhiker's Guide books

Some books call me back on a regular basis:
Stephen King's The Stand
Gael Baudino's The Gossamer Axe
Jane Eyre
Elisabeth Vonarburg's Maerlande Chronicles
Ursula K. LeGuin's Lathe of Heaven, The Dispossessed and The Left Hand of Darkness

And that's just off the top of my head.

I like rereading books.

Which reminds me, I haven't read a Darkover book in ages. I should pick a few up again. :)
Very interesting... I generally *don't* re-read books. I have so many things on my to-be-read shelf that it's hard for me to take time for re-reads.

That said, I *keep* a lot of books, so I better start justifying some of those miles of shelves and get re-reading :-)
I usually have anywhere from 20 to 50 books sitting on my to-be-read pile, plus I have a wishlist of books I want to buy that currently runs to 31 pages in 8pt type.

I re-read for several different reasons, I think. Some books captivate me sufficiently that I want to revisit them from time to time.

Some books I re-read when something I've seen or experienced reminds me of something I'd read before in a particular book, and I want to refresh my memory.

Some books I re-read because they were once very important to me - or occasionally because I didn't like them, when I read them long ago, but they are considered classics with something to offer - and it's been a long time since I've read them, and I want to see how my perceptions of them have changed.

I'm often surprised when I re-read a book by the new insights I have into it because of how I have changed since I last read it.

(Anonymous)

My guilty return rereads include
_The Deed of Paksenarion_ by Elizabeth Moon
_SwordDancer_ and the rest of the series by Jennifer Roberson
_Partners in Necessity_ by Sharon Lee and Steve Miller
And the _Outlander_ series by Diana Gabaldon. Other books in my library get reread too, but those have a special shelf by my bed for when I need a pick-me-up.

Adrianne
I like that image - a little reading haven at your fingertips :-)